Customer Relationship Valuation – Methods and Solutions

In today’s highly competitive business landscape, companies are increasingly recognizing the significance of customer relationships as valuable intangible assets. Building and maintaining strong customer relationships not only drives revenue but also contributes to brand loyalty and long-term sustainability. As a result, understanding and valuing customer relationships have become essential aspects of modern business strategy and financial analysis. In this blog, we will ponder on the factors that are relevant to Customer Relationship Valuation and generally accepted methods for this crucial intangible asset valuation as they apply to these contexts.

What is a Customer Relationship?

Customer relationship refers to the interactions, connections, and associations that a business or organization develops and maintains with its customers over time. It encompasses all aspects of how a company interacts with its customers, including pre-purchase, purchase, and post-purchase interactions. Customer relationships are crucial for building customer loyalty and satisfaction and also generate customer advocacy for long-term business success.

Why is Customer Relationship Valuation required?

Customer relationship valuation is a process used by businesses to assess and quantify the value of their relationships with customers. This intangible asset valuation is required for several important reasons:

  • Strategic Decision-Making: Understanding the value of customer-related assets can inform strategic decisions, such as whether to invest more in customer acquisition, customer retention, or marketing efforts.
  • Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A): In M&A transactions, the value of customer-related assets can significantly impact deal pricing. Buyers are often willing to pay a premium for a company with a strong and loyal customer base.
  • Taxation: Intangible asset valuation, including customer-related assets, can have tax implications. It may affect tax deductions related to amortization or depreciation of these assets.
  • Allocation of the purchase price: Customer relationship also helps in allocating the purchase price in a business combination.
  • Financial Reporting: Customer-related assets are considered intangible assets, and they are required to be reported on a company’s financial statements. Accurate valuation ensures compliance with accounting standards, such as Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) or International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS).
  • Risk Management: Valuation of customer-related assets can help identify risks associated with customer concentration. If a business relies heavily on a small number of customers for a significant portion of its revenue, it may be exposed to risks if those customers reduce their purchases or leave.

Know about the Importance of Brand Valuation and its critical challenges

Customer Relationship Valuation Methods:

Income Approach

The income approach is a method used in business valuation to estimate the value of an asset, business, or in this case, customer relationships, based on the income generated by those relationships. In the context of customer relationships, the income approach seeks to determine the value of those relationships by analyzing the future income they are expected to generate. Another form of income approach is The Multi-Period Excess Earnings Method (MPEEM) and Distributor Method.

Market Approach

The market approach is one of the methods used to value customer relationships. It involves determining the value of customer relationships by comparing them to similar relationships in the market or industry. This approach assumes that the value of your customer relationships is similar to what similar relationships are worth in the open market.

Cost Approach

This approach estimates the value of customer relationships based on the cost to create or replace those relationships. It is particularly relevant when there is no active market for buying or selling customer relationships or when the customer relationships are considered unique to the business.

Application of Multi-Period Excess Earnings Method (MPEEM)

The Multi-Period Excess Earnings Method (MPEEM) is a specialized approach for intangible asset valuation, including customer relationships. This method is often used in business valuation when valuing customer relationships with a focus on their future income-generating potential. The MPEEM extends over multiple periods to account for the expected cash flows generated by these relationships.

To apply the Multi-Period Excess Earnings Method, several key steps are involved:

Identify Customer Relationships

Start by identifying the specific customer relationships or customer base that you want to value. These could be all of your customer relationships or a subset, such as key accounts or a particular segment.

Identify the stream of revenue associated with the Customer Relationships

Identify the revenue stream, or the cash flow, associated with the customer relationships (including the subject asset and any contributory assets necessary to support the earnings associated with the subject asset), over the expected lifespan of the customer relationships. This future revenue stream and cash flow are most commonly estimated using prospective financial information (PFI) prepared by company management and the expected life of Customer Relationships.

Estimate attrition rates for Customer Relationships

When valuing customer-related assets using the MPEEM, identify the portion of revenue expected to be generated through repeat customers existing as of the valuation date. The estimated future revenue is derived from the revenue per customer and the number of retained customers.

Estimate and deduct contributory asset charges

When estimating and deducting contributory asset charges in the context of valuing customer relationships, you are considering the tangible assets and other factors that contribute to the generation of income from those customer relationships.

Discount the remaining cash flow to present value

Apply a discount rate to the projected excess earnings for each period to calculate their present value. Sum up the present values of the excess earnings for each period to arrive at the total value of the customer relationships.

Estimate expenses and cash flow associated with Customer Relationships

Estimating expenses and cash flow associated with customer relationships can be a complex task, as it depends on various factors, including the nature of your business, industry, customer acquisition and retention strategies, and more.

Estimate the rate of return for the subject asset

Estimating the rate of return for customer relationships can be a complex process because it involves assessing the future cash flows or benefits generated by those relationships in relation to the investment or effort required to maintain and nurture them.

Add any tax amortization benefit, if applicable

Tax amortization benefits, if applicable in customer relationships, typically arise from the tax treatment of certain intangible assets. This amortization expense can be deducted for tax purposes, providing a tax benefit.

The Multi-Period Excess Earnings Method is a more sophisticated approach that explicitly takes into account the expected cash flows generated by customer relationships over an extended time horizon. It can be particularly useful when customer relationships are a critical component of a company’s value and when those relationships are expected to contribute to income over several years.

Challenges in customer relationship valuations

Valuing customer relationships can be challenging due to several factors, including the intangible nature of these assets and the complexity of assessing their financial impact.

  • Intangibility: Customer relationships are intangible assets, meaning they lack a physical presence or easily quantifiable characteristics. This makes it challenging to assign a concrete value to them.
  • Subjectivity: Metrics related to customer relationships, such as customer satisfaction scores and Net Promoter Scores (NPS), can be subjective and influenced by individual experiences, making them difficult to standardize.
  • Data Availability: Gathering accurate and comprehensive data on customer relationships, including customer behavior, transaction history, and customer feedback, can be complex and may require sophisticated data analytics.
  • Discount Rate Selection: Determining an appropriate discount rate to use in the valuation process can be challenging. The discount rate should reflect the risk associated with customer relationships.
  • Dynamic Nature: Customer relationships evolve over time due to changes in customer preferences, market conditions, and competition. Valuation methods must account for this dynamic nature.
  • Customer Segmentation: Different customer segments may have varying levels of loyalty and profitability. Valuation should consider the diversity of the customer base and segment-specific factors.
FAQ's

What are the most important types of customer-related intangible assets?

The most important and commonly valued customer-related intangible assets include Customer Relationships, Order Book and Customer Lists. Customer Relationships is the most important customer-related intangible asset that needs to be valued for strategic decision making.

What is a customer list?

A customer list is a properly maintained repository of the details of the people who have bought the products or services of a company at least once. A customer list can include multiple details of its customers, such as customer name, phone number, email address, age, date of birth, and other demographic details.

Which is the most commonly used valuation method for Customer Relationship Valuation?

The Multi-Period Excess Earnings Method (MPEEM), as explained above, is a specialized approach that is the most commonly used for intangible asset valuation, including customer relationships. This method is often used with a focus on the future income-generating potential of the customer relationships being valued.

Conclusion

In conclusion, customer relationship valuation is a critical aspect of business strategy and financial management. In summary, customer relationship valuation is a multifaceted process that provides invaluable insights into the worth of those customer relationships. It supports sound financial management, strategic planning, and risk mitigation, ultimately contributing to a company’s long-term success and competitiveness in the marketplace.

At ValAdvisor, a leading provider of Valuation Services in India, our dedicated team of experts specializes in determining the value of a business or assets, for transactional, accounting, taxation, regulatory, financing, distressed asset resolution, litigation, insurance, strategic, planning, and operational purposes. Our expertise in various advanced models and simulation techniques helps us in delivering reliable and accurate valuations. Count on us to provide tailored solutions that empower you to make informed decisions with confidence.

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Are you looking for valuable insights and expert guidance in the world of business valuation, asset valuation, or complex securities valuation? Look no further! By subscribing to our newsletter, you’re taking a significant step towards unlocking a treasure trove of knowledge that can empower you in making informed business decisions. 

Complex Securities Valuations: Your Go-to Guide

Complex Securities Valuations: Your Go-to Guide

Learn more
Your Guide to Valuation of Crypto Assets

Your Guide to Valuation of Crypto Assets

Learn more
Portfolio Valuation

Portfolio Valuation

Learn more

©2023. ValAdvisor Valuation and Advisory Services Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.