Importance of Contributory Asset Charges (CACs) in Valuation

What are Contributory Assets Charges (CAC)?

In the realm of financial reporting, understanding Contributory Asset Charges is essential for the accurate and transparent valuation of intangible assets in a business combination.

When it comes to determining the value of the primary intangible asset like customer relationships, trademarks, or developed technology, MPEEM provides a systematic and comprehensive way. The fundamental premise of the MPEEM is that the value of an intangible asset is equal to the present value of the net income that is attributable to it. The income streams attributable to the intangible assets are those in excess of the fair returns on all assets that contribute to the income-generating process (‘contributory assets’). CACs generally reflect an estimate of the amount a typical market participant would have to pay to use these contributory assets to generate income with the intangible asset.

Importance of Rule 11UA Valuation

How are the Contributory Asset Charges determined?

The process of determining CACs involves the following steps:

1. Identification of contributory assets:

Contributory asset charges encompass both tangible and intangible assets. Valuation professionals must first identify the assets that support the income-generating assets but are not the primary income generators themselves. Contributory assets include property, plant and equipment, IT infrastructure, and other intangible assets (which could already exist on the balance sheet or be recognized as part of the Purchase Price Allocation exercise, working capital, Assembled workforce, etc.) The assembled workforce is technically not an identifiable intangible asset and is therefore subsumed into goodwill.

2. Assessment of Necessary Level of Contributory Assets:

It is crucial to determine the required level of contributory assets necessary to support the earnings associated with the subject intangible asset from the perspective of market participants. This assessment considers the ongoing and changing needs of the primary asset.

3. Determination of Rates of Return

The rates of return on the various contributory assets are determined based on the perceived riskiness of these assets. Market participants’ expectations and the risk profiles of the contributory assets influence the rates of return. It comprises two elements:

  • The return of element reflects the economic depreciation of the contributory asset that a third party would expect as reimbursement to recover its initial investment in the asset.
  • The return on element is the charge a third party would expect as a profit in addition to the return of investment.

For example, if an entity leases office space, the related lease payment usually reflects the depreciation of the property (i.e., the return of investment or return of contributory asset charge) as well as a profit margin (i.e., the return on investment or return on contributory asset charge).

4. Allocation of Earnings to Contributory Assets:

The application of CACs involves the allocation of earnings to contributory assets. The methodology applied should result in a fair and reasonable distribution of earnings in line with the contributions and risks associated with each asset.

5. Reconciliation of WACC, IRR, and WARA:

The CACs must be reconciled with the overall valuation framework, including the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC), Internal Rate of Return (IRR), and Weighted Average Return on Assets (WARA). This ensures that the charges for the use of contributory assets align with the allocation of earnings appropriately.

Challenges Associated with Contributory Assets Charges

Contributory asset charges can present several challenges when valuing intangible assets. Some of these challenges include:

1. Identifying the Appropriate Contributory Assets

It often requires a comprehensive analysis of various assets and their contributions to earnings. Gathering the necessary data, conducting thorough research, and performing detailed analysis can be time-consuming and challenging, especially when dealing with a diverse range of assets.

2. Complexity of Intangible Assets

Intangible assets, which are commonly valued using the income approach, can be particularly challenging due to their unique characteristics and lack of market-based observable inputs. Determining the appropriate stream of cash flows associated with intangible assets and identifying the contributory assets supporting them can be complex.

3. Determining the Appropriate Rate of Return

It entails determining the fair return on or return of the contributory assets employed in the creation of revenue or cash flow connected with the intangible asset being assessed.





4. Avoiding Double Counting

When applying contributory asset charges, it is critical to prevent duplicate counting, since this might result in an overvaluation of the intangible asset being assessed.

5. Determining the Appropriate Valuation Method

Choosing the best valuation method for an intangible asset can be difficult since there are various options, each with its own set of advantages and disadvantages.

6. Accounting for Non-Operating Assets and Liabilities

NCDs are issued with different terms, allowing investors to choose an option that aligns with their investment goals and risk profile.

7. Need for accurate financial information

CACs are frequently estimated using a company's financial data. The CACs, on the other hand, will be wrong if the financial information is incorrect or incomplete.


8. Need for consistent application

CACs are often calculated using financial data from a company. However, if the financial information is incorrect or partial, the CACs will be incorrect.


9. Need for sensitivity analysis

CACs can be sensitive to changes in the assumptions used to calculate them. Therefore, it is important to perform a sensitivity analysis to assess the impact of changes in these assumptions on the valuation of intangible assets

10. Professional Judgment

Valuation is a complex task that requires professional judgment based on knowledge, experience, objectivity, and independence. However, professional judgment can lead to different conclusions among knowledgeable and reasonable individuals. Balancing subjectivity and objectivity while considering relevant facts and circumstances adds complexity to the process.

11. Evolving Standards and Practices

Valuation practices and standards are continuously evolving, necessitating practitioners to remain updated with the latest developments. Keeping abreast of changes in accounting regulations, industry practices, and emerging market trends can be a challenge in maintaining the accuracy and relevance of valuation methodologies.

Overall, addressing the challenges in identifying contributory assets requires a combination of standardized best practices, professional judgment, continuous learning, and adherence to evolving standards in the valuation profession. 

ValAdvisor Expertise

In conclusion, grasping the concept of Contributory Asset Charges (CACs) is paramount for professionals involved in Purchase Price Allocation (PPA) exercises. For assessing intangible assets’ fair values, recognizing each component’s contribution allows for more precise valuations and enhances financial transparency in reporting practices.

At ValAdvisor, our dedicated team of experts specializes in determining the value of a business or assets, for transactional, accounting, taxation, regulatory, financing, distressed asset resolution, litigation, insurance, strategic, planning, and operational purposes. Our expertise in various advanced models and simulation techniques helps us in delivering reliable and accurate valuations. Count on us to provide tailored solutions that empower you to make informed decisions with confidence.

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Are you looking for valuable insights and expert guidance in the world of business valuation, asset valuation, or complex securities valuation? Look no further! By subscribing to our newsletter, you’re taking a significant step towards unlocking a treasure trove of knowledge that can empower you in making informed business decisions. 

Customer Relationship Valuation – Methods and Solutions

Customer Relationship Valuation – Methods and Solutions

Learn more
Complex Securities Valuations: Your Go-to Guide

Complex Securities Valuations: Your Go-to Guide

Learn more
Your Guide to Valuation of Crypto Assets

Your Guide to Valuation of Crypto Assets

Learn more

©2023. ValAdvisor Valuation and Advisory Services Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.